← All news
18 November 2026

Automated decision-making and the right to complain: two reforms organisations subject to UK data protection law need to get right

The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 (“DUAA”) is the most significant reform of UK data protection law since Brexit. It received Royal Assent on 19 June 2025, and its provisions have since been brought into effect in phases. It amends and supplements the UK GDPR, the Data Protection Act 2018 (“DPA 2018”) and the Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 ("PECR"). Its stated aims are to facilitate the safe and effective use of data, encourage innovation and simplify data protection compliance requirements for organisations. Two reforms stand out for their day-to-day operational impact: The first is the removal of certain restrictions on solely automated decision-making (“ADM”), where there is no “meaningful human involvement” in a decision-making process. The second is a new statutory duty on controllers to implement a data protection complaints-handling procedure.

Automated decision-making: from prohibition to permission with safeguards

What has changed
With effect from 5 February 2026, the DUAA replaced article 22 UK GDPR with new articles 22A to 22D. Under the previous regime, solely automated decisions with legal or similarly significant effects were, in effect, prohibited unless they were based on contract, explicit consent or authorised by law. The new permissive framework reverses this starting point: ADM is generally permitted on any lawful basis, provided prescribed safeguards are in place.
Two restrictions remain. Firstly, where special category data is involved, the existing restrictions remain and ADM may only be carried out with explicit consent, or where the decision is necessary for a contract or required or authorised by law and a substantial public interest condition also applies. Secondly, while reliance on legitimate interests for carrying out ADM can be justified, organisations cannot rely on the new "recognised legitimate interest" lawful basis under the DUAA.

What organisations must do
Under article 22C, controllers carrying out ADM must implement safeguards to uphold the rights, freedoms and legitimate interests of the individual, including to:
- Provide the individual with information about a significant decision taken about them;
- Permit them to make representations about such decision;
- Enable them to obtain human intervention, by someone with the authority and capability to change that decision; and
- Allow them to contest that decision.

The ICO's draft guidance
The ICO has published for consultation some updated draft guidance on ADM and profiling. This will also inform its forthcoming statutory code of practice on AI and ADM. Key points to be aware of include:
- Three-stage scoping test. Is the system making a decision about a person, is it a significant decision having legal or similarly significant effect, and is it solely automated? These questions should be considered "in tandem", and if the answer is yes to all then ADM provisions apply, and safeguards must be implemented.
- A demanding view of "meaningful" human involvement. The human must review each decision before it is applied and have the discretion and authority to alter it. It requires more than a token gesture; ad hoc spot-checking is expressly insufficient, and human involvement only at the design stage does not count.
- Decision-specific explanations. The information safeguard requires an explanation of the actual outcome for the individual, not a repeat of the privacy notice. Its main objective is to empower the person who has been affected by the ADM to meaningfully understand the decision.
- Response timescales. In line with data subject access rights, requests to make representations, obtain human intervention or contest a decision must be acted on without undue delay and within one month, extendable by two months for complex or multiple requests.
Non-compliance risks enforcement action and fines, as well as challenge by affected individuals. As both the final guidance and the AI and ADM code of practice are still awaited, we are continuing to monitor both.
The right to complain: a new statutory complaint-handling duty

What has changed
In another key development, the DUAA has inserted new provisions into the DPA 2018, requiring controllers to facilitate and handle complaints from data subjects about the handling of their personal data. It is one of the few provisions in the DUAA that required most organisations to take proactive steps to comply, with organisations obliged to implement a formal data protection complaints process by 19 June 2026.
If an individual considers that an organisation has infringed data protection legislation in its handling of their personal data (or the personal information of someone they're acting on behalf of) they must be able to make a complaint directly to that organisation. A clear mechanism must be provided for submitting a complaint, there is a 30-day deadline to acknowledge receipt of each complaint, and a formal response must be provided “without undue delay”. The Secretary of State has also been given a regulation-making power to require controllers to notify the ICO of the number of complaints received.

What organisations must do
Organisations are now required to have a robust, documented data protection complaints mechanism in place. This checklist sets out the key requirements:

  1. Provide a clear, accessible route for individuals (or their representatives) to submit complaints directly. This can be via an electronic complaints mechanism, such as an online form, dedicated email address, or alternative route. Organisations can adapt existing data subject rights or customer complaints workflows or implement a standalone procedure. 
  2. Update privacy notices, complaints policies, and relevant internal procedures that explain how individuals can complain and reference the complaint route. 
  3. Assign ownership of the complaints process to an appropriate team. 
  4. Train assigned staff, customer service and HR teams to recognise data protection complaints; and distinguish them from data subject access requests (DSARs), general customer complaints or security incidents. 
  5. Establish a method for logging, tracking, and acknowledging receipt within 30 calendar days, and record progress updates and outcomes. 
  6. Investigate each complaint through a clear process covering information-gathering, escalation, remediation and closure. 
  7. Respond to the complaint without undue delay, including making appropriate enquiries and keeping the complainant informed of progress. 
  8. Adopt governance, training, oversight, and accountability structures for complaints-handling.

Failure to comply is itself an infringement that the ICO can enforce, and poor complaints-handling increases the likelihood that complaints are escalated to the regulator. We are seeing complaints and subject rights requests correspondence increase still further in the UK, arguably at least partly as a result of the new right to complain.

Conclusion

Concluding remarks
Both reforms reflect the DUAA's broader aims to offer greater flexibility for organisations, balanced against stronger, more procedural accountability for individuals. With the stricter restrictions around the use of ADM only remaining in place for decisions involving special category data, businesses have more flexibility to deploy AI tools in the UK (such as in recruitment).
For multinational groups, these are two clear examples of UK divergence from the EU GDPR. Whilst compliance programmes should reflect that divergence, in reality, UK organisations that are also subject to the EU GDPR are likely to keep treating the stricter EU standard as their benchmark.

Article provided by INPLP members: Katie Hewson and Alison Llewellyn, Senior Knowledge Lawyer (Stephenson Harwood LLP, United Kingdom)

By Dr. Tobias Höllwarth